Final Report of the Workshop

Can a Machine be Conscious

The Banbury Center, Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory

May 13-16 2001

Given the great diversity of different views points promulgated at the meeting, tGiven the great diversity of different viewpoints promulgated at the meeting, no single one predominated. The emphasis range from the purely philosophical to the formal, computer-science and algorithmically oriented one, to the more engineering oriented neural network or robotics on, to the fundamental biological or the more systems, psychological view point.

Some of the speakers expressed the belief that the only way to ever build conscious machines is to first understand human or, more broadly, biological based consciousness.

Some speakers argued that the "Global Workspace Model" of Bernie Baars constitutes a viable model for a conscious system.

There appeared to be a broad consensus among the workshop participants that any conscious machine or artifact would need to have a sense of self and purpose and an ability to reason about itself (second-order consciousness). That is not to say that second-order consciousness about self can occur in the absence of first-order consciousness (to be conscious of a percept). But it was generally held that once machines can reason about themselves, can introspect and interact in a meaningful manner with humans, the basic conditions for machine consciousness would be meet.

Other participants argued that none of such functionalities, in and by themselves, would give rise to subjective feelings.

The only (near) universal consensus at the workshop was that, in principle, one day computers or robots could be consciousness. In other words, that we know of no fundamental law or principle operating in this universe that forbids the existence of subjective feelings in artifacts designed or evolved by humans.

In the opinion of one of the organizers (C.K.) progress will come on two unrelated fronts. A better understanding of the neuronal correlates of consciousness in humans and animals will be a conditio sine qua non: We need to know what animals show consciousness (e.g. bees, squid, rodents, monkeys, apes), under what conditions, when does it occur in humans, and, most importantly, what are the minimal neuronal mechanisms necessary for consciousness. Answering these questions will also help us to better understand the function of consciousness. Progress towards machine consciousness will be conditioned on both better understanding the preconditions for biological consciousness as well as on robust means to interact in a natural and robust ways with humans (that is, the development of sophisticated speech and language understanding capability as well as truly autonomous and flexible robots).

Christof Koch
October 2001

Friday, February 23, 2024
About the Swartz Foundation...
The Swartz Foundation was established by Jerry Swartz (bio) in 1994 . . .
Follow us...
The Swartz Foundation is on Twitter: SwartzCompNeuro
2013 Stony Brook Mind/Brain Lecture - Michael Wigler, PhD
2012 Stony Brook Mind/Brain Lecture - John Donoghue
Sloan-Swartz Centers Annual Meeting 2011
2011 Stony Brook Mind/Brain Lecture - Allison J. Doupe
2011 Banbury Workshop
Sloan-Swartz Centers Annual Meeting 2010
2010 Stony Brook Mind/Brain Lecture
Sloan-Swartz Centers Annual Meeting 2009
Conference on Neural Dynamics
2009 Stony Brook Mind/Brain Lecture
Canonical Neural Computation, April 2009
2009 Banbury Workshop
Sloan-Swartz Centers Annual Meeting 2008
Theoretical and Experimental Approaches to Auditory and Visual Attention - Banbury 2008
Stony Brook Mind/Brain 2008: Patricia Smith Churchland, B. Phil. D
Sloan-Swartz Centers Annual Meeting 2007
New Frontiers In Studies Of Nonconscious Processing - Banbury 2007
Stony Brook Mind/Brain 2007: Professor Michael Shadlen, MD, PhD
Multi-level Brain Modeling Workshop 2006
Sloan Swartz Centers Annual Meeting 2006
Banbury 2006: Computational Approaches to Cortical Functions
Stony Brook Mind/Brain 2006: Helen Fisher -- Lecture Videos
Sloan-Swartz Centers for Theoretical Neurobiology
Swartz Center for Computational Neuroscience
Banbury Center Workshop Series
Other Events                           Copyright © The Swartz Foundation 2024